![]() |
![]() |
|
| CLINICAL PROBLEMS CAUSED BY
OBESITY Chapter 13 - Peter G Kopelman March 1, 2002 TO OBTAIN A DOWNLOAD OF THIS CHAPTER IN WORD OR PDF FORMAT, CLICK HERE |
||
|
INTRODUCTION Obesity is now so common within the World's population that it is beginning to replace undernutrition and infectious diseases as the most significant contributor to ill health. Major advances in the understanding of overweight and obesity confirm that they constitute an important medical condition. A better understanding of the genetic contribution to both weight gain and the intra-abdominal distribution of fat (central obesity) is identifying certain ethnic groups and susceptible families who are specifically at risk. Obesity causes or exacerbates a large number of health problems, both
independently and in association with other diseases1. In particular, it
is associated with the development of type 2 diabetes mellitus, coronary
heart disease, an increased incidence of certain forms of cancer,
obstructive sleep apnoea, and osteoarthritis of large and small joints.
The Build and Blood Pressure Study has shown that the adverse effects of
excess weight tend to be delayed, sometimes for 10 years or longer2.
Life insurance data and epidemiological studies confirm that increasing
degrees of overweight and obesity are important predictors of decreased
longevity3. In the Framingham Heart Study, the risk of death within 26
years increased by 1% for each extra pound [0.45kg] increase in weight
between the ages of 30 years and 42 years, and by 2% between the ages of
50 years and 62 years4. Despite this evidence, many clinicians continue
to consider obesity to be a self-inflicted condition of little medical
significance. CLINICAL PROBLEMS CAUSED BY OVERWEIGHT AND OBESITY Increasing body fatness is accompanied by profound changes in physiological function. These changes are, to a certain extent, dependent on the regional distribution of adipose tissue. Generalised obesity results in alterations in total blood volume and cardiac function while the distribution of fat around the thoracic cage and abdomen restricts respiratory excursion and alters respiratory function. The intra-abdominal visceral deposition of adipose tissue, which characterises upper body obesity, is a major contributor to the development of hypertension, elevated plasma insulin concentrations and insulin resistance, hyperglycaemia and hyperlipidaemia. The alterations in metabolic and physiological function that follow an increase in adipose tissue mass are predictable when considered in the context of normal homeostasis. Obesity and type 2 diabetes mellitus Obesity is characterised by elevated fasting plasma insulin and an
exaggerated insulin response to an oral glucose load5. Overall fatness
and the distribution of body fat influence glucose metabolism through
independent but additive mechanisms. Increasing central obesity is
accompanied by a progressive increase in the glucose and insulin
response to an oral glucose challenge with a positive correlation being
observed between increasing upper body (central) obesity and measures of
insulin resistance. Post hepatic insulin delivery is increased in upper
body obesity leading to more marked peripheral insulin concentrations
that, in turn, lead to peripheral insulin resistance.
Obesity and the Metabolic / Insulin Resistance Syndrome In 1988 Reaven coined the term Syndrome X to refer to the clustering of (abdominal) obesity, hypertriglyceridaemia, reduced levels of HDL cholesterol, hyperinsulinaemia, glucose intolerance and hypertension13. To this basic cluster of abnormalities have been added further metabolic alterations that include increased atherogenic small, dense LDL particles, elevated apo B concentrations and raised plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1). The syndrome is now referred to as the Metabolic Syndrome or Insulin Resistance Syndrome, the latter identifying the likely pivotal biochemical abnormality. Reaven estimated that the prevalence of insulin resistance within the sedentary adult population of North America is approximately 25% and closely linked to central (visceral) obesity. Several cohort studies have confirmed that upper body (visceral) obesity is associated with greater cardiovascular morbidity and mortality than obesity itself (14,15). Cardiovascular function in obesity The effects of increased body fatness on cardiovascular function are predictable. Total body oxygen consumption is increased due to an expanded lean tissue mass as well as the oxidative demands of metabolically active adipose tissue, and this is accompanied by an absolute increase in cardiac output. However, the values are within the normal range when they are normalised to body surface area16. The total blood volume in obesity is increased in proportion to body weight. This increase in blood volume contributes to an increase in the left ventricular pre-load and an increase in resting cardiac output17. The increased demand for cardiac output is achieved by an increase in stroke volume while the heart rate remains comparatively unchanged. The obesity-related increase in stroke volume results from an increase in diastolic filling of the left ventricle18. The volume expansion and increase in cardiac output lead to structural changes of the heart. The increase in left ventricular filling results in an increase in the left ventricular cavity dimension and an increase in wall stress. As left ventricular dilatation is accompanied by myocardial hypertrophy, the ratio between ventricular cavity radius and wall thickness is preserved. This thickening of the wall with dilatation results in eccentric hypertrophy. Left ventricular mass increases directly in proportion to BMI or the degree of overweight19. The blood pressure is a function of cardiac output and the vascular resistance against which the blood is pumped - systemic vascular resistance. An elevated cardiac output is common with moderate obesity but not all obese patients are hypertensive. However, in those subjects where systemic resistance is increased, the combination of hypertension and obesity results in an increase of ventricular wall dimensions disproportionate to the chamber radius and this leads, in time, to concentric hypertrophy20 (Figure 2).
In addition to congestive cardiac failure, the presence of left ventricular hypertrophy has been associated with a greater risk of morbidity and mortality from coronary heart disease, CHD and sudden death as well as abnormal heart rhythms, arrhythmias. In the Nurse's Cohort Study the risk of CHD increased twofold for women with a BMI between 25 to 28.9 and 3.6-fold for a BMI >2923. In the Framingham Heart Study, the 26 year incidence of CHD in women and men was related proportionately to excess weight. In this study the incidence of CHD increased by a factor of 2.4 in obese women and a factor of two in obese men under the age of 50 years24. The independent risk of CHD attributed to obesity in multivariate analysis may reflect other important mediators such as upper body fat, altered rheology and haemostasis, hyperinsulinaemia or sleep apnoea. The haemostatic system plays an important role in the pathogenesis of
atherosclerotic plaques and associated complications. A pro-thrombotic
environment and/or a situation where thrombus is not cleared will
predispose to the development of atherosclerosis and its clinical
sequelae. Sleep-breathing abnormalities in obesity An increased amount of fat in the chest wall and abdomen has a predictable effect on the mechanical properties of the chest and the diaphragm and leads to an alteration of respiratory excursions during inspiration and expiration, reducing lung volume and altering the pattern of ventilation to each region. The increased mass of fat additionally leads to a decrease in compliance of the respiratory system as a whole. All of these changes are significantly exaggerated when an obese person lies flat. The mass loading effect of fat requires an increased respiratory muscle force to overcome the excessive elastic recoil and an associated increase in the elastic work of breathing. The obesity-related changes in respiratory function are most important during sleep32,33. During Rapid Eye Movement (REM) sleep, there are decreases in
voluntary muscle tone with reduced arterial oxygen saturation and a rise
in carbon dioxide in all individuals but are especially marked in obese
subjects. Irregular respiration and occasional apnoeic episodes often
occur in lean people during REM sleep but obesity, with its influence on
respiratory mechanics, increases their frequency and may result in
severe hypoxia with resultant cardiac arrhythmias. Studies of obese men
and women have demonstrated that the obstruction occurs in the larynx
and is associated with loss of tone of the muscles controlling tongue
movement. Relaxation of the genioglossus muscle allows the base of the
tongue to fall back against the posterior pharyngeal wall occluding the
pharynx. This results in a temporary cessation of breathing (apnoea) and
associated transient fall in arterial oxygen saturation concentration,
hypoxia. It is not uncommon to observe very low oxygen saturation values
during REM sleep in some obese men while their awake arterial gases are
normal34. By contrast, pre-menopausal obese women show relatively minor
alterations during sleep with a decrease in arterial oxygen saturation
of less than 7% without apnoea. After the menopause, the changes seen in
obese women become more marked with the reduction in oxygen saturation
during sleep being >7% and being accompanied by apnoeic episodes35. A
minority of obese patients develop a situation characterised by a marked
depression in both carbon dioxide (hypercapnic) and hypoxic respiratory
drives accompanied by abnormal and irregular pattern of breathing during
sleep and (eventually) in the waking state36. Characteristically, such
individuals show frequent and prolonged episodes of sleep apnoea - sleep
is disturbed with frequent awakening related to the resumption of
breathing following an apnoeic episode. Daytime somnolence soon
intervenes accompanied by persistent hypoxia / hypercapnia, pulmonary
hypertension (superimposed upon an increased circulatory volume) and
right-sided cardiac failure (figure 3). Such changes constitute the
clinical manifestation of the obesity-hypoventilation syndrome (formerly
known as the Pickwickian syndrome).
Reproductive function in obesity The association between obesity and abnormalities of reproductive
function is well recognized, with decreased libido and impotence
commonly seen in extremely overweight men, and increased incidence of
dysfunctional uterine bleeding and amenorrhoea being reported in obese
women. In obese women, raised plasma testosterone and androstenedione
concentrations are frequently found with a reduced SHBG and increased
ratio of oestrone to oestradiol; it is of interest that a similar
pattern of changes of sex steroid concentration and binding are found in
women with the polycystic ovary [PCO] syndrome, many of whom are obese.
In contrast to the women with the PCO syndrome, obese women have a
normal LH and FSH response to direct stimulation by LH releasing hormone
[LHRH] and normal gonadotrophin release following the administration of
clomiphene, which acts through the hypothalamus40. In obese subjects
weight loss not only reverses the biochemical changes but frequently
results in the reappearance of menses41. Non alcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) is an emerging clinical problem
among obese subjects particularly those with central obesity. 40% of
patients with NASH are overweight or obese, 20% have type 2 diabetes and
20% hyperlipidaemic44. The development of the characteristic
pathological changes within the liver are intimately related to the
various clinical and biological markers of the metabolic syndrome - BMI,
waist circumference, hyperinsulinaemia, hypertriglyceridaemia, and
impaired glucose tolerance. The diagnosis of NASH rests on
characteristic histolological features that include substantial fat
infiltration, necroinflammation and fibrosis in the absence of alcohol
as a cause for the disease. In NASH the ratio of serum alanine
transaminase (ALT) to aspartate transaminase (AST) is always >1
whereas the ratio in alcoholic liver disease is almost always <145.
Histological evidence of fibrosis and/or cirrhosis is seen in up to 50%
of patients with most patients, who initially show fibrosis, developing
cirrhosis after 10 years - it has been suggested that "cryptogenic
cirrhosis" represents "burnt out" NASH46. A liver biopsy
is necessary to make a diagnosis and is important for therapeutic and
prognostic reasons - ultrasound scanning of the liver is not
sufficiently sensitive to be diagnostic. Gallbladder disease is a well-recognised complication of obesity.
Increasing BMI is associated with a substantially increased risk of the
development of gallstones; women with a BMI >45 kg/m2 have a
sevenfold increase compared to normal weight women49. In men, it appears
that the presence of visceral obesity is a stronger risk factor than
body weight per se. It appears likely that a solubility defect leading
to supersatuation of gallbladder bile is the primary reason for the
increased occurrence of gallstones in obesity - obese subjects have
higher bile saturation indices than non-obese individuals, possibly
because of hepatic secretion of cholesterol into bile. Obesity and risk of certain cancers Certain forms of cancer are more common in obese subjects: colorectal
and prostate in obese men, carcinoma of the gallbladder, breast and
endometrium in obese women. The increased incidence is more prominent
for those with upper body fat distribution at lower degrees of obesity
and is thought to be a direct consequence of hormonal changes. The
incidence of gastrointestinal cancers (such as colorectal and gall
bladder) appear to be associated with increased body weight or obesity
in some, but not all, studies while renal cell carcinoma has
consistently been associated with overweight and obesity especially in
women51,52. In addition to overall obesity, intraabdominal fat
distribution and adult weight gain have been independently associated
with increased risk of breast cancer53. Osteoarthritis is the most prevalent joint disorder of an aging
population. The knee is the principal large joint to be targeted by
osteoarthritis (OA) and it results in disabling knee symptoms in an
estimated 10% of patients older than 55 years, a quarter of whom are
severely disabled55. The risk of disability attributable to OA alone is
as great as that due to heart disease and greater than that due to any
other medical disorder in the elderly. A recognised risk factor for the
development of OA is obesity because of increased biomechanical forces
directed at the joint surfaces. Joint alignment of the knee (varus or
valgus alignment) influences the progression of knee OA: the degree of
radiographic tibiofemoral narrowing correlates with increasing BMI in
those subjects with varus knees56. It appears that varus mal-alignment
is a local factor that predisposes the knee to the adverse biomechanical
effects of obesity irrespective of whether mal-alignment precedes or
follows OA. Obesity may be associated with the development of other medical
complications. These include gastro-oesophageal reflux secondary to a
hiatus hernia, skin problems including oppositional intertrigo, lower
limb oedema and varicose veins, excessive sweating, and increased
frequency of psychological and psychiatric problems. In addition, the
major limiting factor for most obese subjects is breathlessness on minor
exertion such as climbing stairs and walking uphill. ASSESSMENT OF THE OBESE PATIENT Clinical setting: The usual principles for a medical consultation are
applicable to the assessment of an overweight or obese patient. The
consultation room must be properly equipped with larger than average
chairs, access for wheelchairs for patients with mobility problems and
medical equipment of appropriate size (examination couch, blood pressure
cuff, weighing scales and tape measure).
Clinical examination: An outline of a scheme for the clinical examination is given in Table 2.
Assessment of risk: An assessment of an obese patient's absolute risk status requires an assessment of associated disease conditions (established CHD, other atherosclerotic diseases, type 2 diabetes and sleep apnoea), other obesity-associated diseases such as gynaecological abnormalities, osteoarthritis, gallstones and stress incontinence, and cardiovascular risk factors. These will include cigarette smoking, hypertension, high-risk LDL-cholesterol (>4 mmol/l), low HDL-cholesterol (<1 mmol/l), impaired fasting blood glucose and family history of premature CHD. Patients can be classified as being of high absolute risk if they have three of these risk factors; such patients usually require specific management of risk factors. Cigarette smoking: In the obese patient who smokes, smoking cessation is a major goal for risk management. A major obstacle to smoking cessation is the attendant weight gain. The weight gained with smoking cessation is less likely to produce negative health consequences compared to continued smoking. The initial screening tests for the obese patient should include a full blood count (a raised MCV may be associated with an excessive alcohol intake, an increased PCV may be seen in obstructive sleep apnoea and occasionally in Cushing's syndrome), plasma urea and electrolytes (raised sodium and hypokalaemia in Cushing's), fasting blood glucose to exclude diabetes mellitus, and thyroid functions tests. The urine should be tested for protein. Suspected cardiac abnormalities: It is important to identify those obese patients who are particularly at risk from cardiovascular complications at an early stage because the prognosis is poor once the disease becomes advanced. A high index of clinical suspicion is the most sensitive diagnostic test because an electrocardiogram, exercise ECG and trans-thoracic echocardiographs often lack diagnostic power due to difficulty in interpretation. Nevertheless, echocardiography and radionucleotide stress tests are generally helpful - severe exercise intolerance makes exercise ECGs rarely practical. Suspected respiratory abnormalities: The "gold standard" for the assessment of sleep-breathing abnormalities is an overnight sleep study (polysonography) with sleep staging, measures of airflow at the nose/mouth, measures of respiratory effort, oxygen saturation and simultaneous ECG and electromyography. The sleep study should report the number of respiratory events, such as apnoea, and the degree of oxygen desaturation. Overnight oximetry (which can be performed in outpatients) will detect repetitive oxygen desaturation and may be diagnostic in some patients. However, its use is limited because it does not record apnoeic episodes. Suspected endocrine abnormalities: It is important to consider the likelihood of an endocrine disorder in an obese patient before embarking upon a series of tests of endocrine function. Such investigations cannot be justified unless there is good historical and clinical evidence to support a diagnosis other than simple obesity. Possible Cushing's syndrome in an obese patient: A common clinical problem is excluding Cushing's syndrome in patients with obesity. The usual screening test is the measurement of urinary free cortisol concentration in a 24-hour urine collection. If the results are equivocal then a dexamethasone suppression test is appropriate. This is most conveniently done by giving 1mg as a single dose or, if a formal "low dose" dexamethasone suppression test is indicated, 0.5mg 6-hourly. Blood for cortisol is taken before and after 48 hours at 0900h; the subsequent cortisol is suppressed by at least 50% of its original value in obesity. Corticotrophin-releasing hormone (CRH) has been demonstrated to stimulate ACTH secretion in normal weight human subjects and patients with Cushing's disease but not in the ectopic ACTH syndrome. In obesity, the cortisol and ACTH release after CRH are comparable to that seen in normal weight subjects which contrasts with the generally excessive rise seen in pituitary-dependent Cushings or the absence of a response found in an adrenal adenoma or ectopic ACTH. Thus, a combination of low-dose dexamethasone suppression with CRH test may provide the most sensitive and specific method for differentiating Cushing's syndrome. Possible pituitary dysfunction in an obese patient: Subtle changes in anterior pituitary function may be associated with extreme obesity. Such changes, which should be taken into account when evaluating the results from anterior pituitary tests. Results from investigations that make pituitary dysfunction unlikely are as follows:
The measurement of serum leptin is not recommended as a routine, but
in cases of severe, early-onset obesity this should be undertaken, as,
although rare, congenital leptin deficiency is a potentially treatable
disorder. Diagnostic tests for other possible causes or associations of obesity: These investigations will depend largely on clinical suspicion and may include:
SUMMARY OF CLINICAL PROBLEMS CAUSED BY OBESITY Figure 4 summarises the pathophsyiological mechanisms that lead to
the major clinical problems associated with obesity. The figure
identifies an increasing adipocyte (fat) mass as the central factor.
This results in an increasing mechanical "strain" on important
body systems and alterations in metabolic function resulting in
hyperinsulinaemia and insulin resistance.
Weight loss (with a reduction in fat mass) will result in either an alleviation of many of these problems, or their resolution if achieved at an early stage. Too often, unfortunately, medical intervention occurs too late when the complications are established, and irreversible. |
|||||||||||||